Understanding Insurance Claim Denials and Delays in Injury Cases

Why do disputes or delays happen even in clear-cut serious injury cases?

Even in clear cases, disputes or delays can occur due to the gray areas in law, particularly concerning damages. Issues like pain and suffering, related medical bills, preexisting conditions, and valuation of personal property can be subject to dispute. An insurance company may admit fault but may not agree with the claimant’s assessment of what is fair or necessary to cover.

What does an insurance company do to evaluate a claim after an accident?

Insurance companies use various methods to evaluate claims. Some use computer programs that analyze input data to suggest settlement amounts, while others hold round table discussions with adjusters for larger claims. Typically, adjusters have a limit to the authority they can exert on a claim, and higher-ups are involved for more significant cases. The company’s approach can vary based on the size and severity of the case.

How is AI being used by insurance companies in claim evaluations?

Insurance companies have long used data-driven models, similar to how baseball teams use statistics to strategize. They use algorithms and AI to analyze medical codes, geographical data, and other factors to assess exposure and determine offers. This approach helps predict the likelihood of a plaintiff accepting a settlement.

What are common reasons insurance companies deny or delay claims?

Claims can be denied if the insurance company believes their insured is not at fault or if there is a coverage issue, such as a policy exclusion or lapsed policy due to nonpayment. Delays can occur for strategic reasons, such as encouraging a lower settlement acceptance, or due to logistical issues like adjusters being overwhelmed with cases due to high turnover.

What should people know before agreeing to give a recorded statement to an insurance company?

It’s crucial to differentiate between requests from your own insurance company and the other party’s insurer. Your policy may require cooperation, but this doesn’t mean giving a full recorded statement. For the other party’s insurer, it’s generally advised to avoid giving statements, as they can be used against you later, especially if you’re not in the best condition due to medication or injuries.

How do gaps in medical treatment affect insurance claims?

Gaps in treatment are red flags for insurance companies. They may use a treatment gap to argue that any subsequent medical issues are unrelated to the accident. It’s important to follow medical recommendations to avoid gaps, as this can significantly impact the insurance company’s evaluation and the outcome of the claim.

Can you share a case where an initial denial was overturned based on further investigation?

In a case where the police report incorrectly indicated our client was at fault, further investigation with accident reconstruction and video evidence revealed the other party was responsible. This changed the outcome from a denied claim to a significant seven-figure settlement.

What should someone do if they feel an insurance company is not treating their claim fairly?

If someone feels their claim is unfairly delayed or denied, they should understand that it might be due to broader company strategies or logistical issues. It’s often necessary to engage a lawyer to ensure the claim is taken seriously, which can involve filing a lawsuit or having a lawyer send a formal letter to elevate the claim’s priority.